The St. Louis Cardinals are facing a pivotal moment in their 2025 season as veteran right-hander Erick Fedde struggles to maintain form, leaving the rotation in flux. After a strong start to the year, Fedde’s recent outings have raised concerns within the organization. Over his last five starts, Fedde has posted an ERA north of 6.00, with declining velocity and command issues that have become difficult to ignore.
Manager Oliver Marmol and the Cardinals front office are reportedly weighing their options, and one name continues to surface: Michael McGreevy. The 2021 first-round draft pick has been quietly putting together an impressive campaign in Triple-A Memphis. McGreevy, 24, boasts a sub-3.00 ERA, solid WHIP, and a reputation for pounding the strike zone. His consistency and development have positioned him as the most MLB-ready arm in the Cardinals’ system.
With the Cardinals hovering around .500 and every game critical in the tightly contested NL Central, the pressure is mounting. The club has made no official decision, but insiders suggest McGreevy could be called up if Fedde falters again in his next outing.
“We’re monitoring everything closely,” said President of Baseball Operations John Mozeliak. “We’re committed to putting the best team on the field, and that means making tough decisions.”
McGreevy’s promotion could signal a shift toward youth for the Cardinals, who have relied heavily on veteran pitching in recent years. If he gets the nod, fans can expect a poised and polished righty ready to make his mark.
As the trade deadline approaches, how the Cardinals handle this rotation dilemma could define their second-half success—and shape the future of their pitching staff.
