Philadelphia can be an unforgiving city for athletes, with fans often quick to criticize when things go wrong. But when it comes to the Phillies’ broadcast crews, there is little for supporters to complain about. In fact, Awful Announcing’s latest MLB local broadcaster rankings placed Philadelphia’s announcing team sixth-best in baseball.
Tom McCarthy remains the centerpiece of the Phillies’ television coverage. The New Jersey native has been part of the organization for more than 20 years, aside from a brief two-year stint with the New York Mets, and has served as the club’s primary play-by-play voice since Harry Kalas’ death in 2009. At 58, McCarthy has developed into one of the more respected voices in the sport.
Alongside him is former Phillies star John Kruk, a key member of Philadelphia’s 1993 National League championship team. Kruk’s humor, personality and impeccable comedic timing have made him a fan favorite, with many supporters wishing he could be part of every broadcast.
The television crew also features several former Phillies, including Ruben Amaro Jr., Ben Davis and 2008 World Series MVP Cole Hamels. Although Amaro remains a polarizing figure because of his previous tenure running the organization’s baseball operations, the group has generally provided strong analysis and entertainment.
Philadelphia’s radio booth is just as impressive. Scott Franzke has been the team’s primary radio play-by-play announcer since 2006 and works alongside longtime analyst Larry Andersen and former 1993 Phillies shortstop Kevin Stocker.
Phillies Announcers Earn Recognition
The Phillies’ broadcast teams received some deserved recognition Wednesday when Awful Announcing published its annual rankings based on feedback from nearly 10,000 fans.
Philadelphia landed sixth overall, trailing only the Chicago Cubs, New York Yankees, New York Mets, San Francisco Giants and San Diego Padres.
Much of the praise focused on the chemistry between McCarthy and Kruk. Fans described McCarthy as one of the most underrated sportscasters in the country, while Kruk was widely celebrated for his unique personality and entertainment value.
Franzke also received strong reviews, with fans recognizing him as one of baseball’s premier radio voices. Hamels earned praise for his occasional contributions during Sunday home broadcasts as well.
Phillies supporters have enjoyed outstanding broadcasters across multiple generations. Those who grew up listening to Harry Kalas and Richie Ashburn now have McCarthy, Kruk, and Franzke carrying that tradition forward.
Fortunately for Philadelphia fans, none of the current group is particularly close to retirement, meaning their voices could remain a major part of Phillies baseball for years to come.
